Regulating Financial Services in an Era of Technological Disruption

Nicholas Morris | Bio
La Trobe Law School, La Trobe University
Sue Jaffer | Bio
La Trobe Law School, La Trobe University


Financial regulators are challenged to respond to the innovation opportunities presented by financial technology (fintech). Current rules are not necessarily sufficient or effective to adequately regulate new business models and new products relating to innovations such as crypto assets or digital financial services. Regulators that fail to respond in a timely manner may drive innovation offshore and deprive their markets and consumers of appropriate, new services. To respond to new financial innovation, regulators have been establishing innovation hubs and regulatory sandboxes. Innovation hubs enable them to engage innovators more effectively. Sandboxes allow the products to be tested in a controlled environment and enable to regulator to consider whether existing laws are appropriate to regulate such products and, of not, what measures may be required. Sandboxes are however resource intensive and they hold a number of risks. Financial regulators are, of course, not alone in having to address the regulatory challenges of innovation. This article therefore also considers other non-financial regulatory experiences of innovative products and services, namely automated vehicles; emissions trading in China; and Uber and its clones, to consider whether those experiences hold lessons for financial regulators.



Accenture. 2019. “Top 10 Banking Trends for 2019: A Potential Tipping Point”
Alliance for Financial Inclusion, 2018. “FinTech for financial inclusion: A Framework for Digital Financial Transformation”
Anderson, J., Kalra, N., Stanley, K.; Sorensen, P., Samaras, C., Oluwatobi A. 2016. "Autonomous Vehicle Technology: A Guide for Policymakers". RAND Corporation, Accessed on 16 Jan 2019.
Appaya, S. 2018. “Sandbox or Quicksand? 13 Dec 2018.
ASIC, 2017. “ASIC’s Innovation Hub and our approach to regulatory technology: Report 23”.
ASIC, 2019. “Global Finance Innovation Network”,
Austrac, 2017a. “Joint media release: International Financial Intelligence Unit Codeathon 2017”. 20 Nov 2017.
Austrac, 2017b. “Register now for the first international financial intelligence codeathon”. 19 Sep 2017.
Austrac, 2018. “Register now for the ASEAN-Australia Codeathon”.
Austroads and NTC, 2017. “Guidelines for trials of automated vehicles in Australia”, NTC, May 2017. Accessed 14 Jan 2019
Baker McKenzie. 2017. “A guide to regulatory fintech sandboxes across Asia Pacific”
Baxi, A. 2019. “Google Pay Is Evolving Into A Platform To Grab A Slice Of India's Growing Digital Economy” Forbes
BCG, 2017. “Unlocking Cities: The impact of ridesharing in Southeast Asia and beyond” Nov 2017.
Brian, M. 2017. “UK government finally draws up laws for autonomous cars.” Engagdet, 23 Feb 2017. Accessed on 27 Jan 2019
Broeders, F. and Prnio, J. “Innovative technology in financial supervision (suptech) – the experience of early users” FSI Insights on policy implementation No 9 (July 2018)
Buckley, R. P., Arner, D. W., Veidt, R. and Zetzsche, D. A. 2019. “Building FinTech Ecosystems: Regulatory Sandboxes, Innovation Hubs and Beyond” UNSW Law Research Paper No. 19-72. or
Bureau of Consumer Financial Protection, 2019. “Policy on No-Action Letters”, 10 Sept 2019,
Cai, C. W. 2018. “Disruption of financial intermediation by FinTech: a review on crowdfunding and blockchain.” Accounting & Finance, 58(4), 965-992.
Cambridge Centre for Alternative Finance. 2018. “Guide to Promoting Financial & Regulatory Innovation: Insights from the UK.” p. 9.
Central Bank of Ireland, 2018. “Innovation Hub: 2018 Update”
Centre for Connected and Autonomous Vehicles, 2018. “UK connected & autonomous vehicle research and development projects 2018”, July 2018. Accessed on 27 Jan 2019
Centre for the Study of the Presidency & Congress, 2017. “The autonomous vehicle revolution” Accessed on 3 Nov 2018
CGAP. 2019. “China: A Digital Payments Revolution.” Research & Analysis Publication.
Chan, N. 2016. “What does it take to build a ‘Hong Kong Brand’ for financial services?”
Chatain, Pierre-Laurent & Zerzan, Andrew & Noor, Wameek & Dannaoui, Najah & Koker, Louis. (2011). Protecting mobile money against financial crime : global policy challenges and solutions. ResearchGate.
Committee on Payments and Market Infrastructures, 2018 “Central Bank Digital Currencies” Bank for International Settlements, Research and Publications
Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, 2016. Project Catalyst report: Promoting consumer-friendly Innovation - Innovation Insights (2016) 11-15
de Waal, J., Gray, J., and Hougaard, C. 2019. “Regulating for innovation: An evolving frame” Cenfri
Deloitte Centre for Regulatory Strategy. 2018. “A journey through the FCA regulatory sandbox: The benefits, challenges, and next steps.”
Deloitte, 2018. “A journey through the FCA regulatory sandbox”
Department of Infrastructure, Regional Development and Cities, ND. “Testing of Automated vehicles”, Available at, Accessed on 14 Jan 2019
di Castri, S. & Plaitakis, A. 2017. “Going beyond regulatory sandboxes to enable FinTech innovation in emerging markets.” BFA Global, p. 5.
di Castri, S., Hohl, S., Kulenkampff, A and Prenio, J. 2019. “The suptech generations” FSI Insights on policy implementation No 19 (2019)
Dudley, G., Banister, D. and Schwanen, T. 2017. “The Rise of Uber and Regulating the Disruptive Innovator”, Political Quarterly, May 2017
Duff, S. 2017. “Modernising Digital Financial Regulation” The Aspen Institute
el Hassan, Z. 2015. “Financial Services: Regulation Tomorrow” Norton Rose Fulbright Blog Network, 12 May 2015,
Etzioni, A. and Etzioni, O. 2017. "Incorporating Ethics into Artificial Intelligence". The Journal of Ethics 21 (4): 403–418. doi:10.1007/s10892-017-9252-2
FAFT, 2019. “Money laundering risks from “stablecoins” and other emerging assets” 18 October 2019
FCA, 2014. “Project innovate: Call for input. Feedback Statement FS14/2”.
FCA, 2015. “Regulatory sandbox”, November 2015,
FCA, 2015a “Innovate and Innovation Hub”,
FCA, 2016. “Consumer Access TechSprint” 18 April 2016
FCA, 2018a. “Global Financial Innovation Network (GFIN)”, August 2018,
FCA, 2018b. “Global Financial Innovation Network consultation”, 7 August 2018,
FCA, 2019a. “2019 Global AML and Financial Crime TechSprint.” 29 July 2019.
FCA, 2019b. “GFIN cross-border testing pilot – next steps” 29 April 2019,
FCA, 2019c. “The Impact and Effectiveness of Innovate”, April 2019,
FIBR, 2017. “Inclusive Digital Ecosystems of the Future (FIBR Project White Paper No. 2)” FIBR 2017.
Finance Magnates, 2018. “FCA and ASIC Sign Enhanced Cooperation Agreement for Fintech Innovation” Finance Magnates, Fri 23/03/2018,
Financial Stability Board, 2019a. “FinTech and market structure in financial services Market developments and potential financial stability implications.”
Financial Stability Board, 2019b. “Regulatory issues of stablecoins”
Frey, C.B. and Osborne, M.A. 2017. "The future of employment: How susceptible are jobs to computerisation?". Technological Forecasting and Social Change. 114: 254–280. CiteSeerX doi:10.1016/j.techfore.2016.08.019. ISSN 0040-1625.
FSD Kenya, 2018. “Groundbreaking new policy and regulatory initiatives may spur more fintech innovation in Kenya”, 5 July 2018.
Gao, P., Hensley, R. and Zielke, A. 2014. “A roadmap to the future for the auto industry”, McKinsey Quarterly, October 2014. Accessed on 14 Jan 2019
Global Financial Innovation Network, 2019. “GFiN One Year On: The Global Financial Innovation Network Reflects on Its First Year”
GPFI, 2016. “Global Standard-Setting Bodies and Financial Inclusion: The Evolving Landscape”
Gray, V. 2006. “The un-wired continent: Africa’s mobile success story”, ITU
Grigg, A. 2018. “China launches world’s largest carbon trading scheme.” The Australian Financial Review 19 Dec 2017.
GSMA 2017a. “Accelerating affordable smartphone ownership in emerging markets,”
GSMA, 2017b. “State of the industry report on mobile money”,
GSMA, 2018a. “The mobile economy Asia”.
GSMA, 2018b. “The mobile economy Sub-Sahara”,
GSMA, 2018c. “Beyond the basics: How smartphones will drive future opportunities for the mobile money industry”
Haering, M. 2019. “The valuation of banks in a more fragmented market” Finextra Blog article,
Huertas, M. 2018. “The UK FCA’s Regulatory ‘Sandbox’: Any Lessons for the EU?” Journal of International Banking Law and Regulation, Vol.33, Issue 2
Hughes, N. and Lonie, S. 2007. “M-PESA: Mobile Money for the “Unbanked” Turning Cellphones into 24-Hour Tellers in Kenya” MIT Press Journals, Winter/Spring 2007.
ITU, 2016. “ITU Facts and Figures 2016” ITU.
Jean-Francois Bonnefon, J.F., Shariff, A., and Rahwan, I. 2016. “The social dilemma of autonomous vehicles”, in Science June 2016 Vol 352 Issue 6293.
Jenik, I. 2018. “Briefing on Regulatory Sandboxes’ United Nations Secretary-General’s Special Advocate”
Jenik, I. and Lauer, K. 2017. “Regulatory Sandboxes and Financial Inclusion” CGAP, Working Paper
Keahey, K. Doering, K. and Foster, I. "From sandbox to playground: Dynamic virtual environments in the grid." Proceedings of the 5th IEEE/ACM International Workshop on Grid Computing. IEEE Computer Society, 2004.
KPMG, 2016a. “No U-turn: How autonomous vehicles will reshape our cities” Accessed on 14 Jan 2019.
KPMG, 2016b, “No U-Turn”, , Accessed on 14 Jan 2019
Kwak, J. 2013. “Cultural Capture and the Financial Crisis” in D. Carpenter and D. Moss (eds.) Preventing Capture: Special Interest Influence in Legislation, and How To Limit It. Cambridge, UK: University Press.
Lafrance, A. 2016. "How Self-Driving Cars Will Threaten Privacy”, The Atlantic, 21 March 2016 Accessed on 17 Jan 2019
Libra. 2019. “Libra White Paper” Available at:
Lin, T. C. 2015. “Infinite financial intermediation.” Wake Forest L. Rev, 50: 643
Lyman, T. Pickens, M. and Porteous, D. 2008. “Regulating Transformational Branchless Banking: Mobile Phones and Other Technology to Increase Access to Finance” CGAP Focus Note 43
Masciandaro, D. and Quintyn, M. 2013. "The Evolution of Financial Supervision: the Continuing Search for the Holy Grail," in Morten Balling and Ernest Gnan (eds.) 50 Years of Money and Finance - Lessons and Challenges Brussels, Belgium: Larcier pp. 263-318.
Mazer, R. and Rowan, P. “Competition in Mobile Financial Services: Lessons from Kenya and Tanzania.” CGAP (2016)
Mbise, T., Taal, S., Roberts, M. and Lammersen, F. 2018 “Digital Connectivity & E-Commerce: Overview of Financing Flows and Examples of Aid for Trade Support” World Trade Organization Economic Research and Statistics Division Staff Working Paper 2018-08 (2018)
McHenry, P. 2017. “CFPB’s ‘project catalyst’ failed. Fintech deserves better” American Banker 25 April 2017
McKinsey Centre for Future Mobility, 2019. “An integrated perspective on the future of mobility, Part 3: Setting the direction towards seamless mobility”, Available at Accessed on 18 Jan 2019
Moore, M. 1995. Creating Public Value: Strategic Management in Government Cambridge. MA: Harvard University Press
Morningstar Equity Analysts, 2018. “Uber could be worth $110bn at IPO” Morningstar. 31 July 2018.
Mumbere, D. 2018. “Digital in 2018: Africa's internet users increase by 20%”. Africa News 6 Feb 2018.
Muthiora, B. 2015. “Enabling Mobile Money Policies in Kenya Fostering a Digital Financial Revolution.” GSMA.
National Transport Commission, 2017a. Guidelines for Trial of Automated Vehicles in Australia,
National Transport Commission, 2017b. Regulatory Options to Assure Automated Vehicle Safety in Australia Discussion Paper, June 2017. Accessed on 14 Jan 2019
National Transport Commission, 2018a, “Changing driving laws to support automated vehicles: Policy paper”, May 2018, Accessed on 27 Jan 2019
National Transport Commission, 2018b “Safety assurance for automated driving systems: Decision regulation impact statement”, Nov 2018, Accessed on 27 Jan 2019
National Transport Commission, ND. “Automated vehicles in Australia”,
NSW Government, ND. “Regulatory Sandboxes”
Office of the Australian Information Commissioner, 2019. “OAIC joins with global privacy regulators to call for more information from the Libra Network” August 2019,
Patterson, J. 2016. “FCA, ASIC Ink FinTech Deal, Easing Barriers to Entry For Startups”, Finance Magnates, Wed 23/03/2016,
Perkins, A. 2018. “Government to review law before self-driving cars arrive on UK roads.” The Guardian, Wed 7 Mar 2018. Accessed on 14th Jan 2019
Policy Interns, 2018. “Regulatory Sandboxes: The Future of Financial Technology”.
Pompeu, C. and de Koker, L., Mendelson, D. and Watts, D. 2017. “Regulation of Big Data: perspectives on strategy, policy, law and privacy” 2017 Health and Technology, Vol. 7, No. 4, pp. 335-34.
Prevelakis, V., & Spinellis, D. 2001. “Sandboxing Applications” USENIX Annual Technical Conference, FREENIX Track (pp. 119-126)
Rai, S. 2019. “Facebook Moves Closer to WhatsApp Payment Service Debut in India”
Rapier, G. 2018. “People are attacking Waymo’s self-driving cars in Arizona by slashing tires and, in some cases, pulling guns on the safety drivers, in Business Insider Australia, Dec 13 2018. Accessed on 8 Jan 2019
Reserve Bank of Fiji, 2019. “Press Release No 19 - Media Note Roadshow on World First Regional Regulatory Sandbox Commences with Fiji Visit”,
Royal Commission into Misconduct in the Banking, Superannuation and Financial Services Industry. 2018. Final Report Volume 1
Shenzhen Municipal Government (SZMG) 2014 “Interim administrative measures for carbon emissions trading in Shenzhen” (in Chinese)
Shroff, R. 2018. “The investor perspective on driving financial inclusion through technology”, 28 Nov 2018.
Staschen, S. and Dermish, A. “Balancing Regulatory Uncertainty in Branchless Banking Design” CGAP Blog, 1 May 2014.
Taiebat, M., Brown, A., Safford, H., Qu, S. and Xu, M. 2018. "A Review on Energy, Environmental, and Sustainability Implications of Connected and Automated Vehicles". Environmental Science & Technology. 52 (20): 11449–11465. doi:10.1021/acs.est.8b00127. PMID 30192527
Telenor Group, 2005. “GSMA makes mobile phones cheaper”.
Tesfaye, M. 2018. “The FCA's fintech sandbox is already delivering value” Business Insider Australia Oct 12 2018,
Thomas, L. 2018. “The Case for a Federal Regulatory Sandbox for Fintech Companies”, Banking Institute Journal Vol 22 (2018) Iss 1
Toronto Centre 2017 “Regulatory Sandboxes”, TC Notes November 2017,
Transport and Infrastructure Council, 2017. “Transport and Infrastructure Council Communique”, 10 Nov 2017 Accessed on 27 Jan 2019
Transurban, 2018. “Victorian trials phase one – findings and recommendations”, April 2018. Accessed on 14 Jan 2019
Truby, J. 2018. “Fintech and the city: Sandbox 2.0 policy and regulatory reform proposals” International Review of Law, Computers & Technology, DOI: 10.1080/13600869.2018.1546542
Turner, J., “AI Armageddon: Robot Struck Down By Self-Driving Tesla Car”, Techco, 8 Jan 2019. Accessed on 27 January 2017.
UNSGSA FinTech Working Group and CCAF, 2019. “Early Lessons on Regulatory Innovations to Enable Inclusive FinTech: Innovation Offices, Regulatory Sandboxes, and RegTech”
Weschler, M, Perlman, L. and Gurung, N. "The State of Regulatory Sandboxes in Developing Countries",, accessed on 22 November 2019.
World Economic Forum. 2017. “Beyond Fintech: A Pragmatic Assessment Of Disruptive Potential In Financial Services.” Future of Financial Services Series (2018)
World Economic Forum. 2018 “The New Physics of Financial Services – How artificial intelligence is transforming the financial ecosystem”,
Wright, T. 2018. “A cautionary tale – trials of automated vehicle on Victorian roads” Maurice Blackburn Blog, Accessed on 13 Jan 2019
Xiao, B. and Wibawa, T. 2019 “China passes cryptography laws, laying framework for a national digital currency” ABC News, 30 October 2019,
Zetzsche, D. A., Buckley, R. P., Barberis, J. N., Arner, D. W. 2017. “Regulating a revolution: From regulatory sandboxes to smart regulation”. Fordham Journal of Corporate and Financial Law, 23(1), 31-104
Zhang, Z. X., 2015. “Carbon Emissions Trading in China: The Evolution from Pilots to a Nationwide Scheme”, CCEP Working Paper 1503, Australian National University,
How to Cite
de Koker L, Morris N, Jaffer S. Regulating Financial Services in an Era of Technological Disruption . LiC [Internet]. 2020Feb.26 [cited 2021May9];36(2):90-112. Available from:

Send mail to Author

Send Cancel