Australia’s International and Domestic Borders as Sites of Dislocation, Division and Distrust: The Socio-Political Impacts of COVID-19 Travel Bans

Share:

Abstract

In response to the COVID-19 pandemic, Australia deployed some of the strictest border controls in the world. Aus-tralia’s international and domestic travel restrictions and border closures were introduced to save lives and protect health by preventing or reducing the spread of COVID-19. Nevertheless, early research indicates that the rigid man-ner in which they were implemented and the length of time for which they continued contributed to loss of life, led to the onset and exacerbation of serious medical conditions and plunged some people into poverty or extreme finan-cial distress. In this article, we take these observations further by drawing on transitional justice scholarship to sug-gest that public accounts written by people affected by these border restrictions indicate a deeper national malaise. Consistent themes in these public accounts indicate erosion of trust in government, a sense of betrayal by public authorities, a feeling of disconnection from fellow Australians and a sense of no longer having a ‘home’. We argue that these tropes mirror findings on the consequences of displacement in transitional justice studies and indicate the need for a process and period of healing and reconciliation once the nation emerges out of the pandemic. We con-clude by outlining the potential role of a ‘people’s inquiry’ in fostering these outcomes.

References

1. ABC News, 2022. ““I am very relieved” WA Disabil-ity Community Welcomes Delay Border Opening Delay.” Online, 21 January. https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-01-21/%E2%80%98i-am-very-relieved%E2%80%99-disability-community-welcomes-border-delay/13724036 Accessed 3 March 2022.
2. Al Jazeera, 2020. “Coronavirus: Travel Restrictions, Border Shutdowns by Country.” 3 June
https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2020/6/3/coronavirus-travel-restrictions-border-shutdowns-by-country Accessed 1 February 2023.
3. Ali, K. et al. 2022. “A Cross-Sectional Investigation of the Mental Health and Wellbeing Among Individuals who have been Negatively Impacted by the COVID-19 International Border Closure in Australia.” Globi-lization and Health, 18 (12). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12992-022-00807-7.
4. Australian Lawyers for Human Rights, 2021. “Brief-ing Note: Australian Government’s India Travel Ban.” 4 May
https://alhr.org.au/wp/wp-content/uploads/2021/05/04-05-21-ALHR-Briefing-Note-on-Indian-Travel-Ban-F2.pdf Ac-cessed 31 January 2023.
5. Australian Peoples’ Tribunal, 2021. “Citizen’s In-quiry into the 2019/2020 Australian Bushfires: Did Systemic Failure by Australian Governments, to Care for Country, Contribute to “Ecocide”?”
https://tribunal.org.au/hearings/2021-tribunal/ Accessed 2 February 2023.
6. Balint, J., Evans, J. and McMillan, N. 2014. “Rethink-ing Transitional Justice, Redressing Indigenous Harm: A New Conceptual Approach.” The Interna-tional Journal of Transitional Justice, 8 (2): 194–216.
7. Barber, R. and Fang Law, S. 2020. “Exposing Ine-quality in Australia: Are We all In it Together?” So-cial and Health Sciences, 18 (2): 96–115.
8. Bolt, A. 2021. “Cruel India Travel Ban.” The Herald Sun, Sydney, 2 May.
9. Bradley, M. 2005. “The Conditions of Just Return: State Responsibility and Restitution for Refugees.” Working Paper No 21, Refugee Studies Centre, The University of Oxford, March.
10. Bradley, M. 2013. “Truth-Telling and Displacement: Patterns and Prospects.” June. Research Brief, In-ternational Center for Transitional Jus-tice/Brookings LSE https://www.brookings.edu/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/TJ_TruthTelling.pdf Ac-cessed 2 February 2023.
11. Briskman, L. 2020. “The People’s Inquiry into De-tention: Social Work Activism for Asylum Seeker Rights.” Journal of Sociology, 56 (1): 100–114.
12. Briskman, L., Latham. S. and Goddard, C. 2008. Hu-man Rights Overboard: Seeking Asylum in Austral-ia. Carlton, Australia: Scribe.
13. Butler, J. 2019. Frames of War: When is Life Grieva-ble? New York, USA: Verso.
14. Byrnes, A. 2017. (ed). Peoples’ Tribunals and Inter-national Law. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge Universi-ty Press.
15. Coyle, K. 2022. “Applying Transitional Justice Frameworks to the United States after COVID-19.” E-International Relations, 29 October. https://www.e-ir.info/pdf/99591 Accessed 28 January 2023.
16. Credlin, P. 2022. “Inquiry into Australia’s Pandemic Handling “Must be a Royal Commission”.” Sky News Australia, online, 4 April. https://www.skynews.com.au/opinion/peta-credlin/inquiry-into-australias-pandemic-handling-must-be-a-royal-commis-sion/video/da91a4546cd3282ee2c454a0cf1a0941 Accessed 5 April 2022.
17. Davies, S. and di Piramo, D. 2022. “Spotlight on the Gendered Impacts of COVID-19 in Australia: A Gen-der Matrix Analysis.” Australian Journal of Human Rights, 28 (1): 74–94.
18. Dekker, M. 2021. “What Now, After the Long-Awaited Homecoming?” Northern Rivers Times, Ca-sino, 23 December.
19. Duthie, R. 2011. “Transitional Justice and Displace-ment.” The International Journal of Transitional Justice, 5 (2): 241–261.
20. Evershed, N. 2021. “Data Reveals Australia’s new International Arrivals Cap is Harshest Yet.” The Guardian, online, 7 July https://www.theguardian.com/news/datablog/2021/jul/07/australias-travel-restrictions-how-the-cap-on-international-arrivals-has-changed Ac-cessed 9 July 2021.

21. First Peoples’ Assembly of Victoria, 2021. ““Tyerri Yoo-rrook” (Seed of Truth) Report to the Yoo-rrook Justice Commission from the First Peoples’ Assembly of Victoria.” 1 June.
22. Fitzsimmons, C. 2021. ““Lack of Empathy and Sympathy”: Formerly Stranded Aussies Adapt to Life Back Home.” The Sydney Morning Herald, online, 28 March. https://www.smh.com.au/national/lack-of-empathy-and-sympathy-formerly-stranded-aussies-adjust-to-life-back-home-20210317-p57bjn.html Accessed 30 June 2021.
23. Gilmartin, N. 2021. ““Ending the Silence”: Addressing the Legacy of Displacement in Northern Ireland’s “Troubles”.” International Journal of Transitional Justice, 15: 108–127.
24. Grattan, M. 2022. “With Australia’s Omicrom Death Toll Mounting, The Argument for a COVID Royal Commission Grows.” The Conversation, online, 28 January. https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-01-28/australia-omicron-death-toll-covid-royal-commission-argument/100785730 Accessed 12 February 2022.
25. Guest, K. 2021. ““A Spoilt Brat Country”: The Australians Overseas who Decided not to Come Home.” The Guardian, online, 2 January. https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2021/jan/02/a-spoilt-brat-country-the-australians-overseas-who-decided-not-to-come-home Accessed 27 Mary 2021.
26. Gunia, A. 2021. “After Australia Banned its Citizens in India From Coming Home, Many Ask: Who is Really Australian?” Time, online, 19 May. https://time.com/6047130/australia-india-covid-travel-ban/ Accessed 2 February 2023.
27. Halton, J. et al. 2021. “National Review of Quaran-tine.” 15 November. https://apo.org.au/node/315124 Accessed 28 No-vember 2021.
28. Harris Rimmer, S. 2010. “Reconceiving Refugees and Internally Displaced Persons (IDPs) As Transi-tional Justice Actors.” Contemporary Readings in Law and Social Justice, 2 (2): 163–180.
29. Hope, Z. 2021. ““People Are Broken”: Queenslanders Made Homeless for Months Prepare to Cross Border.” Brisbane Times, online, 11 December. https://www.brisbanetimes.com.au/national/queensland/people-are-broken-queenslanders-made-homeless-for-months-prepare-to-cross-border-20211211-p59gqr.html. Accessed 12 December 2021.
30. Horne, C. 2023. “Trust and Transitional Justice.” in Lavinia Stan and Nadya Nedelsky (eds), Encyclope-dia of Transitional Justice (Second Edition). Cam-bridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, forthcom-ing. Pre-print version available at https://cynthiamhorne.weebly.com/uploads/8/9/9/8/8998042/trust_and_transitional_justice_cynthia_horne_-_final_encyclopedia_of_tj.pdf Accessed 1 February 2023.
31. Ison, R. 2021. “As Australia’s Covid Border Restrictions Lift, I’m Nervous about Returning Home. Here’s Why.” ABC News, online, 4 November. https://www.abc.net.au/news/2021-11-04/borders-open-after-covid-closures-but-australians-aboard-hurt/100585994 Accessed 3 March 2022.
32. Jefferies, R., McAdam, J. and Pillai, S. 2021. “Can we Still call Australia Home? The Right to Return and the Legality of Australia’s COVID-19 Travel Re-strictions.” Australian Journal of Human Rights, 27 (2): 211–231.
33. Kagi, J. 2021. “Critics Blast Federal Government’s ‘Immoral and Un-Australian’ Ban on Citizens Re-turning from India.” ABC News, online, 2 May. https://www.abc.net.au/news/2021-05-02/india-return-policy-labelled-immoral-and-un-australian/100109898 Access 2 February 2023.
34. Karp, P. and Visontay E. 2020. “Australia's Cap on Arrivals During Covid Pandemic may Break Inter-national Laws.” The Guardian, online, 22 October. https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2020/oct/22/australias-cap-on-arrivals-during-covid-pandemic-may-break-international-laws Accessed 21 October 2020.
35. Keynes, M. 2019. “History Education for Transi-tional Justice? Challenges, Limitations and Possibili-ties for Settler Colonial Australia.” The Internation-al Journal of Transitional Justice, 13 (1): 113–133.
36. King, J. and Smee, B. 2021. ““No Compassion”: Why Thousands of Queenslanders Remain Stranded on the NSW Border.” The Guardian, online, 28 Novem-ber. https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2021/nov/28/no-compassion-why-thousands-of-queenslanders-remain-stranded-on-the-nsw-border Accessed 1 February 2022.
37. Lackey, B. 2021. “Australian Man Dies in Freezing Cold Waiting for Border to Reopen.” MSN News, online, 2 December. https://www.msn.com/en-au/news/australia/death-of-man-78-stuck-in-a-freezing-caravan/ar-AARoz7S Accessed 3 Decem-ber 2021.
38. Luoma, C. 2021. “Closing the Cultural Rights Gap in Transitional Justice: Developments from Canada’s National Inquiry into Missing and Murdered Indige-nous Women and Girls.” Netherlands Quarterly of Human Rights, 39 (1): 30–52.
39. Mao, F. 2021. “Australians Stuck Overseas “Aban-doned” by their Own Country.” BBC News, online, 1 May.
https://www.bbc.com/news/world-australia-56924188 Accessed 30 August 2021.
40. Marder, I. 2020. “What Does Justice Look Like Dur-ing and After COVID-19? A Report from the Fourth European Meeting on Restorative Justice and COVID-19.” 15 July. https://www.euforumrj.org/en/what-does-justice-look-during-and-after-covid-19 Accessed 20 January 2023.
41. Marder, I. and Rossner, M. 2021. “Restorative Jus-tice During and After COVID-19.” The International Journal of Restorative Justice, 4 (2): 305–314.
42. Massola, J. 2021. “Labor MPs Call for a Royal Com-mission into Coronavirus Response.” The Sydney Morning Herald, online, 1 August. https://www.smh.com.au/politics/federal/labor-mps-call-for-a-royal-commission-into-coronavirus-response-20210722-p58c5m.html Ac-cessed 12 March 2022.
43. Mather, H. 2022. “Dear Mark McGowan: I've Been Silent for Two Years. But Enough is Enough.” Ma-maMia, online, 21 January. https://www.mamamia.com.au/wa-border-opening-news/?fbclid=IwAR2-DfkT_TdgWOs1JPpfeEEkPW8lRdCTWm95O_L9UvjZ-3K7LUwV4hxFe1Q. Accessed 3 February 2022.
44. Matthews, R. 2021. “Australia is Turning its Back on Citizens Stranded by India Travel Ban.” The Herald Sun, 4 May. https://www.heraldsun.com.au/travel/travel-news/australia-is-turning-its-back-on-citizens-stranded-by-india-travel-ban/news-story/136374d0c91e9acee057791ab9bad5f6 Ac-cessed 2 February 2023.
45. Mazzucato, C. 2020. “To Heal COVID 19 Wounds We Need a Truth and Reconciliation Commission: Re-flections from Lombardy, Italy.” European Forum for Restorative Justice, https://publicatt.unicatt.it/handle/10807/162419 Accessed 27 January 2023.
46. Mbembé, A. (translated by Meintjes, L.) 2003. “Ne-cropolitics.” Public Culture, 15 (1): 11–40.
47. McAdam, J. 2007. Complementary Protection in In-ternational Law. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
48. McAdam, J. and Jefferies, R. 2021. “Why the Latest Travel Caps Look Like an Arbitrary Restriction on Australians’ Right to Come Home.” The Conversa-tion, online, 5 July. https://theconversation.com/ why-the-latest-travel-caps-look-like-an-arbitrary-restriction-on-australians-right-to-come-home-161882 Accessed 2 December 2021.
49. McDermid, P. et al. 2022. “Psychological and Finan-cial Impacts of COVID-19 Related Travel Measures: An International Cross-Sectional Case Study.” PLoS ONE 17(8): e0271894. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0271894.
50. McGaughy, F. et al. 2022 “International Human Rights Law – Lessons in the Era of COVID-19.” Aus-tralian Journal of Human Rights, 27 (2): 189–210.
51. Menachery Paulose, R. 2021. (ed). Peoples’ Tribunals, Human Rights and the Law. London, UK: Routledge.
52. Mills, T. 2021. “India Travel Ban Unconstitutional, Made Under Dictatorial Power: Geoffrey Robertson.” Sydney Morning Herald, online, 4 May. https://www.smh.com.au/national/india-travel-ban-unconstitutional-made-under-dictatorial-power-geoffrey-robertson-20210503-p57oht.html Accessed 2 February 2023.
53. Nagy, R. 2013. “The Scope and Bounds of Transitional Justice and the Canadian Truth and Reconciliation Commission.” The International Journal of Transitional Justice, 7 (1): 52–73.
54. O’Flaherty, A. 2021. “People left Stranded and Unable to Come Home Amid New Qld Border Restrictions.” ABC News, online, 27 August. https://www.abc.net.au/news/2021-08-27/border-restrictions-leave-qlders-scrambing-to-find-accommodation/100411342 Accessed 20 December 2021.
55. Ogg, K. 2022. “Is Australia’s Outward Travel Ban in Breach of International Human Rights Law?” 19 August. https://law.anu.edu.au/research/essay/covid-19-and-international-law/australia%E2%80%99s-outward-travel-ban-breach-international Accessed 20 August 2020.
56. Ogg, K. and Simic, O. 2022a. “Becoming an Internal-ly Displaced Person in Australia: State Border Clo-sures During the COVID-19 Pandemic and the Role of International Law on Internal Displacement.” Australian Journal of Human Rights, 28 (1): 95–117.
57. Ogg, K. and Simic, O. 2022b. “Lived Experiences of Australia’s International and Domestic COVID-19 Border Closures.” COVID-19, Borders, and the Law, The University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong, 24–25 May 2022.
58. Oslender, U. 2016. “The Banality of Displacement: Discourse and Thoughtlessness in the Internal Ref-ugee Crisis in Colombia.” Political Geography, 50: 10–19.
59. Oster, C. et al. 2022. “The Experience of Individuals Affected by Australia’s International Border Closure During the COVID-19 Pandemic.” Health & Place, 78. DOI: 10.1016/j.healthplace.2022.102928.
60. Parmentier, S. 2021. “Dealing with the Harm after COVID-19: What Potential for Transitional Justice?” The International Journal of Restorative Justice, 4 (2): 321–327.
61. Parliament of Australia, ND. “Senate Select Commit-tee on COVID-19.”
https://www.aph.gov.au/Parliamentary_Business/Committees/Senate/COVID-19/COVID19 Accessed 13 January 2022.
62. Parry, P. 2016. Transitional Justice and Displace-ment: Lessons from Liberia and Afghanistan. PhD thesis, The Australian National University.
63. People’s Covid Inquiry, 2021. “Misconduct in Public Office: Why Did So Many Thousands Die Unnecessarily?: Full Report.” 1 December. https://www.peoplescovidinquiry.com/_files/ugd/360851_310fe297a8ec410dba2f5888d6ff3d19.pdf Accessed 30 September 2022.
64. People’s Inquiry into Detention, 2006. “We’ve Boundless Plains to Share: First Report of the Peo-ple’s Inquiry Into Detention.” November. http://www.safecom.org.au/pdfs/peoples-inquiry-first-report.pdf Accessed 2 February 2023.
65. Prime Minister of Australia, 2020. “Border Re-strictions” (Media Release, 19 March) https://www.pm.gov.au/media/border-re-strictions#:~:text=Australia%20is%20closing%20its%20borders%20to%20all%20noncitizens,immedi-ate%20family%2C%20including%20spouses%2C%20legal%20guardians%20and%20dependants Accessed 27 November 2022.
66. Prime Minister’s Office, UK, 2021. “Prime Minister Announces COVID-19 Inquiry Chair.” 15 December
https://www.gov.uk/government/news/prime-minister-announces-covid-19-inquiry-chair Accessed 21 January 2022.
67. Public Accountability Committee, Parliament of New South Wales, 2022. “Final Report.” 25 March.
68. Public Accounts and Estimates Committee, Parliament of Victoria, 2021. “Inquiry into the Victorian Government’s Response to the COVID-19 Pandemic: Final Report.” February.
69. Purkey, A. 2016. “Justice, Reconciliation, and Ending Displacement: Legal Empowerment and Refugee Engagement in Transitional Justice Processes.” Refugee Survey Quarterly, 35 (4): 1–25.
70. Reveggino, B. and Becerra-Bolanos, A. 2022. “Tran-sitional Justice after the COVID-19 Pandemic.” In-ternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 19 (19): 12388.
71. Schaffer, K. and Smith, S. 2004. Human Rights and Narrated Lives: The Ethics of Recognition. New York, USA: Palgrave Macmillan.
72. Select Committee, Parliament of the Australian Capital Territory, 2020. “Inquiry into the COVID-19 Pandemic Response: Final Report.” 13 October.
73. Senate Select Committee on COVID-19, Parliament of Australia, 2022. “Final Report.” 7 April.
74. Simic, O. 2022. “Australia, Covid-19, and the India Travel Ban.” Griffith Journal of Law and Human Dignity, 9 (2): 35–70.
75. Smee, B. 2021. “Queensland Border Opening: Stranded Travellers Begin Arriving amid Concerns about Covid Testing Delays.” The Guardian, online, 10 December. https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2021/dec/10/qld-border-opening-fears-of-long-delays-at-checkpoints-amid-surge-in-stranded-travellers Accessed 12 December 2021.
76. Stewart, C. 2021. “How Long Can We Keep Shutting Out The World?” The Weekend Australian, online, 26 June. https://www.theaustralian.com.au/weekend-australian-magazine/fortress-of-fear-how-long-can-australia-keep-shutting-out-the-world/news-story/7a7ab97e6bf011333b8984f12d714ed7 Accessed 15 February 2022.
77. Stollznow, K. 2020. “Home for Christmas?” Fifteen EightyFour: Academic Perspectives from Cam-bridge University Press, online, 12 November. http://www.cambridgeblog.org/2020/11/home-for-christmas/ Accessed 15 March 2022.
78. Terms of Reference, UK COVID-19 Inquiry, 2022. June.
https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/uk-covid-19-inquiry-terms-of-reference Accessed 25 January 2023.
79. Thorn, A. 2020. “PM ‘Blames’ Aussies abroad for Struggle to Return Home.” Australian Aviation, online, 26 August. https://australianaviation.com.au/2020/08/pm-blames-aussies-abroad-for-struggle-to-return-home/ Accessed 24 January 2021.
80. UN Human Rights Committee, 1992. “General Comment No 20 (1992): Prohibition of Torture, or other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment.” UN Doc HRI/GEN/1/Rev.1. 10 March.
81. UN Human Rights Committee, 1999. “General Comment No 27 (1999): Freedom of Movement (Article 12 of the International Covenant of Civil and Political Rights).” UN Doc CCPR/C/21/Rev.1/Add.9. 1 November.
82. UN Human Rights Committee, 2019. “General Comment No 36 (2019): Article 6: Right to Life.” UN Doc CCPR/C/GC/36. 3 September.
83. UN Human Rights Committee, 2020. “Statement on Derogations From the Covenant in Connection with the COVID-19 Pandemic.” UN Doc CCPR/C/128/2. 30 April.
84. Victorian Ombudsman, 2021. “Investigation into Decision-Making Under the Victorian Border Cross-ing Permit Directions.” 7 December.
85. Yarwood, L. 2012. “Women, Transitional Justice and Indigenous Conflict: The Role of Women in Ad-dressing New Zealand’s Colonial Past.” in Lisa Yar-wood (ed). Women and Transitional Justice: The Experience of Women as Participants. Abingdon, UK: Routledge, 2012, 8.
How to Cite
1.
Simic O, Ogg K. Australia’s International and Domestic Borders as Sites of Dislocation, Division and Distrust: The Socio-Political Impacts of COVID-19 Travel Bans. LiC [Internet]. 2023Mar.9 [cited 2024Jun.17];38(1). Available from: https://journals.latrobe.edu.au/index.php/law-in-context/article/view/195

Send mail to Author


Send Cancel