Litigating Racial Profiling: The Use of Statistical Data

Tamar Hopkins  
PhD candidate, University of New South Wales, NSW, Australia
Share:

Abstract

The use of statistical data to prove racial discrimination by police in individual cases is relatively novel in Australia.  Based on a survey of international strategies, this article argues that statistical and social science data can play three critical evidential roles in litigation. Firstly, it can form part of the social context evidence used to influence the inferences that can be drawn from other evidence led in a case.  Secondly it can influence the cogency of the evidence required for claimants to meet the standard of proof, and thirdly, it can be used to shift the burden of proof.  Using these evidential methods, evidence of institutional racism can be used to assist in making findings of discrimination in individual cases. This article speculates on the role that statistics could have played in the Haile-Michael race discrimination claim that settled in 2013, and in the 2019 inquest into the death of Tanya Day.

References

1. Agarwal, R., Lalani, F., and Boutilier, M. 2018. "Lessons from Latif: Guidance on the Use of So-cial Science Expert Evidence in Discrimination Cases." Canadian Bar Review, 96 (1): 36-56.
2. Barnes, G. 2019. “Lifetime Traffic Penalty Com-parison, Briefing Note.” WA Police, released un-der FOI to Guardian Australia, 13 February 2019.
3. Baumgartner, F., Epp, D., and Shoub, K. 2018. Suspect Citizens, What 20 Million Traffic Stops Tell Us about Policing and Race. Cambridge, UK. Cambridge University Press.
4. Boon-Kuo, L., Brodie, A., Keene-McCann, J., Sen-tas, V., and Weber, L. 2020. “Policing biosecurity: police enforcement of special measures in New South Wales and Victoria during the COVID-19 pandemic.” Current Issues in Criminal Justice. 33 (1): 76-88.
5. Bonilla-Silva, E. 2014. Racism without Racists. Maryland USA, Rowman and Littlefield Publish-ers Inc, Fourth Ed.
6. Bowling, B. and Phillips, C. 2007. "Disproportion-ate and Discriminatory: Reviewing the Evidence on Police Stop and Search." Modern Law Review, 70 (6): 936-961.
7. Burtis, M., Gelbach, J., and Kobayashi, B. 2017. "Error Costs, Legal Standards of Proof and Statis-tical Significance." Faculty Scholarship 1754: 1-40.
8. Carmichael, S. and Hamilton, C. 1967. Black Pow-er, The Politics of Liberation. NY, USA: Random House.
9. Chan, J. 2011. "Racial Profiling and Police Sub-culture." Canadian Journal of Criminology and Criminal Justice, 53 (1): 75-76.
10. de Plevitz, L. 2003. “Briginshaw 'Standard of Proof' in Anti-Discrimination Law: 'Pointing with a Wavering Finger.'” Melbourne University Law Review, 27 (2): 308-333.
11. Dixon, D., Bottomley, A. K., Coleman, C. A., Gill, M., and Wall, D. 1989. "Rules and Reality in the Construction and Regulation of Police Suspicion." International Journal of the Sociology of Law, 17: 185-206.
12. Dunn, C. and Shames, M. 2019. Stop and Frisk in the de Blasio Era. New York Civil Liberties Union, March 2019.
13. Epp, C. R., Maynard-Moody, S., and Haider-Markel, D. 2014 Pulled over: How Police Stops De-fine Race and Citizenship. Chicago, US: University of Chicago Press.
14. Faruqi, O. 2020. "Compliance Fines under the Mi-croscope". The Saturday Paper, online, 18 April https://www.thesaturdaypaper.com.au/news/health/2020/04/18/compliance-fines-under-the-microscope/15871320009710
15. Foster, L., Jacobs, L., and Siu, B. 2016. "Race Da-ta and Traffic Stops in Ottawa, 2013-2015 : A Re-port on Ottawa and the Police Districts." Submit-ted to the Ottawa Police Board.
16. Fridell, L. 2004. "By the Numbers: A Guide for Analyzing Race Data from Vehicle Stops." Police Executive Research Forum.
17. Gordon, I. 2012a. First Report of Professor Gordon (Redacted) Hail-Michael v Konstantinidis VID 969 of 2010, 11 September 2012, 23.
18. Gordon, I. 2012b. 2nd Expert Report of Ian Gor-don, Filed in Haile-Michael & Ors in the Federal Court of Australia on 13/11/2012.
19. Goris, I. 2009. Profiling Minorities: A Study of Stop and Search Practices in Paris (Open Justice Socie-ty). https://www.justiceinitiative.org/publications/profiling-minorities-study-stop-and-search-practices-paris Accessed 115/11/2020
20. Hall, Stuart. 1999. “From Scarman to Stephen Lawrence.” History Workshop Journal, 48: 187-197.
21. Hopkins, T. 2007. “Complaints against police be-havior in Flemington.” Alternative Law Journal, 32, (1): 32-36.
22. Hopkins, T. 2017. Monitoring Racial Profiling In-troducing a Scheme to Prevent Unlawful Stops and Searches by Victoria Police A Report of the Police Stop Data Working Group. Police Stop Da-ta Working Group.
23. Tamar Hopkins (2020) “Litigating racial profil-ing: examining the evidence for institutional ra-cial profiling by police against African-Australians in Flemington, Victoria” Australian Journal of Human Rights, 26 (2): 209-226, DOI: 10.1080/1323238X.2021.1872132
24. Lamberth, J. and Buckman, W. 2001. "Challeng-ing Racial Profiles: Attacking Jim Crow on the In-terstate". Rutgers Race and the Law Review, 3: 83-115.
25. Marlow, A. and Loveday, B. 2000. “Race, Policing and the Need for Leadership” in After Macpher-son, Policing After the Stephen Lawrence Inquiry. Dorset, UK: Russell House Publishing.
26. McNeilly, G. 2018. Broken Trust Indigenous Peo-ple and the Thunder Bay Police Service. Office of the Independent Complaint Review Director, De-cember 2018, 208.
27. Miller, J. and MVA. 2000. Profiling Populations Available for Stops and Searches. UK: Home Of-fice.
28. Moeckli, Daniel. 2007. “Stop and Search Under the Terrorism Act 2000: A Comment on R (Gillan) v Commissioner of Police for the Metropolis”. The Modern Law Review, 70 (4): 659-670.
29. Open Society Justice Initiative. 2016. “Seydi and Others v France: Application”. 8 May 2016, https://www.justiceinitiative.org/litigation/seydi-and-others-v-france
30. Quinlan, T. and Derfoufi, Z. 2015. “Counter Ter-rorism Policing”, in Michael Shiner Rebekah Del-sol and Michael Shiner Rebekah Delsol, Stop and Search, The Anatomy of a Police Power. Hamp-shire, UK: Palgrave, Macmillan, 123-145.
31. Sentas, V. 2014. Traces of Terror Counter-Terrorism Law, Policing, and Race. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
32. Sentas, V. and Pandolfini, C. 2017. Policing Young People in NSW A Study of the Suspect Tar-geting Management Plan, NSW: Youth Justice Coalition.
33. Sheppard, C. and Chabot, M. L. 2018. "Obstacles to Crossing the Discrimination Threshold: Con-necting Individual Exclusion to Group-Based Ine-qualities." Canadian Bar Review, 96 (1): 1-35.
34. Shiner, M. et al. 2008, The Colour of Injustice, ‘Race’, Drugs and Law Enforcement in England and Wales, Stopwatch, Release.
35. Shiner, M. and Thornbury, P. 2019. Regulating Police Stop and Search: An Evaluation of the Northamptonshire Police Reasonable Grounds Panel, Open Society Justice Initiative.
36. Siu, B. 2017. “Defining the Concept of Racial Pro-filing: A Discussion”. Canadian Diversity, 14(1): 11-13.
37. Skolnick, J. H. and Fyfe, J.J. 1993. Above the Law, Police and the Excessive Use of Force New York: The Free Press.
38. Stuart, F. 2016. Down, out and under Arrest. Po-licing and Everyday Life in Skid Row. Chicago, USA: University of Chicago Press.
39. Tanovich, D. M. (2017). Applying the racial pro-filing correspondence test. Criminal Law Quar-terly, 64(3-4): 359-383.
40. Taylor, K-Y. 2016. From #BlackLivesMatter to Black Liberation. Chicago, USA: Haymarket Books.
41. Van Maanen, J. 1978. ‘The Asshole’ in Tim New-burn (ed) 2005, Policing, Key Readings. Oxford-shire, UK: Routledge.
42. Weber, L. 2020. You’re Going to Be in the System Forever: Policing, Risk and Belonging in Greater Dandenong. Melbourne: Monash University.
43. Williams, P. and Clarke B. 2016. Dangerous Asso-ciations: Joint Enterprise, Gangs and Racism, Cen-tre for Crime and Justice Studies.
44. Williams, P. 2018. Being Matrixed: The (Over) Po-licing of Gang Suspects in London London, UK: StopWatch.
45. Wortley, S. and Owusu-Bempah, A. 2011. “The Usual Suspects: Police Stop and Search Practices in Canada”. Policing and Society, 21 (4): 395-407.
46. Wortley, S. 2019. Halifax, Nova Scotia: Street Checks Report (Nova Scotia Human Rights Com-mission, March 2019) https://humanrights.novascotia.ca/sites/default/files/editor-up-loads/halifax_street_checks_report_march_2019_0.pdf
47. Wortley, S. and Jung, M. 2020. Racial Disparity in Arrests and Charges Toronto, Ontario Human Rights Commission.
How to Cite
1.
Hopkins T. Litigating Racial Profiling: The Use of Statistical Data. LiC [Internet]. 2021Sep.3 [cited 2021Sep.26];37(2). Available from: https://journals.latrobe.edu.au/index.php/law-in-context/article/view/155

Send mail to Author


Send Cancel