The Cultural, Economic and Technical Milieu of Social Media Misconduct Dismissals in Australia and South Africa

René Cornish   | Bio
Queensland University of Technology, Brisbane
Kieran Tranter | Bio
Queensland University of Technology, Brisbane
Share:

Abstract

The intersection between social media activity and employment is an emerging global issue. This article examines the cultural, economic and technical milieu that has generated contested social media misconduct dismissals in Australia and South Africa. Through an analysis of 42 Australian and 97 South African decisions, it is argued that the ubiquitous, enduring and open nature of social media affects employment quite differently depending on country specific factors. In Australia, the absence of entrenched political rights has meant that employee social media use is not subject to reasonable expectations of privacy. However, there is also tolerance for a certain level of larrikin behaviour. In South Africa, the existence of enshrined rights manifests differently in the context of social media dismissal. Within a culturally diverse population with deeply fractured race relations, the decisions reveal a White minority still perpetuating dominance over a historically disadvantaged Black workforce.

References

Anderson, G., Brodie, D., and Riley, J. 2017. The Common Law Employment Relationship: A Comparative Study. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar Publishing Limited.
Anwar, Mohammed Amir. 2017. "White people in South Africa still hold the lion's share of all forms of capital." The Conversation. https://theconversation.com/white-people-in-south-africa-still-hold-the-lions-share-of-all-forms-of-capital-75510.
Arnold, B. 2020. “Eyes Wide Shut: Homosociality, Justice and Male Rape through an Australian Lens.” In K. Weinert, K. Crawley and K. Tranter (eds.) Law, Lawyers and Justice: Through Australian Lenses. London, UK: Routledge.
Australian Law Reform Commission, Serious Invasions of Privacy in the Digital Era (Report No 123, 2014). https://www.alrc.gov.au/publication/serious-invasions-of-privacy-in-the-digital-era-alrc-report-123/ Accessed 29/03/2020.
Banghart, S., Etter, M., and Stohl, C. 2018. “Organizational Boundary Regulation Through Social Media Policies.” Management Communication Quarterly, 32 (3): 337- 378.
Barnes, A., Balnave, N., and Holland, P. 2018. “Utterly Disgraceful”: Social Media and The Workplace.” Australian Journal of Public Administration, 77 (3): 492- 499.
Bellanta, M. 2012. Larrikins: A History. St Lucia, Qld: University of Queensland Press.
Broad-Based Black Economic Empowerment Commission, National Status and Trends Transformation 2018 (Wed page) https://www.bbbeecommission.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/National-Status-Trends-on-Black-Economic-Empowerment-Report-31-March-2019-Approved-FINAL.pdf.
Bellanta, M. 2013. “The Leary Larrikin.” Ozwords, 22 (1): 1-3.
Brown, D., Roberson, T., and Sullivan, L. 2012. “I see what you did there: The use of social networks to gather evidence.” Southern Law Journal, 22 (2): 241- 267.
Buchbach, J. 2017. Social Media Policies and Work: Reconciling Personal Autonomy Interests and Employer Risks. Ph.D. thesis, Queensland University of Technology, Brisbane.
Cassim, F. 2015. “Regulating hate speech and freedom of expression on the Internet: Promoting tolerance and diversity.” South African Journal of Criminal Justice, 28 (3): 303- 336.
Cilliers, F. 2013. “The Role and Effect of Social Media in the Workplace.” Northern Kentucky Law Review, 40 (3): 567 – 592.
Coetzee, S. 2019. “A Legal Perspective on Social Media Use and Employment: Lessons for South African Educators.” PER/Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal, 22, https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2019/v22i0a5778
Cohen, N. 2018. “How culture affects street-level bureaucrats’ bending the rules in the context of informal payments for health care: The Israeli case.” American Review of Public Administration, 48 (2): 175 – 187.
Commission of Employment Equity, 19th Commission of Employment Equity Annual Report 2018-2019 (Wed page) https://www.labourguide.co.za/workshop/1692-19th-cee-annual-report/file
Corney, A. 2014. “Unfair Dismissal Relating to the Use of Social Media – An Analysis of Case History.” Canberra Law Review, 12 (1): 144 – 188.
Cowling, D. 2019. Social Media Statistics Australia – September 2019. https://www.socialmedianews.com.au/social-media-statistics-australia-september-2019/ Accessed 18/10/2019.
Davidson, H. 2006. “Former SBS reporter Scott McIntyre repeats Anzac Day accusations on Twitter.” The Guardian, 25 April.
Davis, M. 2015. “Social media policies: balancing individual expression, privacy and employment obligations.” Privacy Law Bulletin, 12 (6): 163-166.
Dimitrova, K., Rahmanzadeh, S., and Lipman, J. 2013. “Justine Sacco, Fired After Tweet on Aids in Africa, Issues Apology.” ABC News, Sydney, 22 December.
Du Toit, D. 2016. “The Right to Equality v Employer Control and Employee ‘Subordination’: Are Some More Equal Than Others?” Industrial Law Journal, 37 (1): 1-27.
Du Toit, D. et al. 2006. Labour Relations Law: A Comprehensive Guide. Durban, South Africa: LexisNexis Butterworth.
Dugard, J. 2015. Human Rights and the South African Legal Order. Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press.
Duvenhage, J. 2017. Social Media in the Workplace: Legal challenges for employers and employees. Master of Law thesis, University of Notre Dame, Australia.
Forsyth, A. 2014. “A Thin Wall of Privacy Protection, with Gaps and Cracks: Regulation of Employees’ Personal Information and Workplace Privacy in Australia.” In R. Blanpaint et al. (eds.) Protection of Employees’ Personal Information and Privacy. Bulletin of Comparative Labour Law Series 88, Wolters Kluwer, pp. 7 -33.
French, R. 2015. “Human Rights Protection in Australia and the United Kingdom: Contrasts and Comparisons.” Brief, 42 (2): 14 – 21.
Galligan, B., and Morton, F.L. 2006. “The Australian Exceptionalism: Rights Protection without a Bill of Rights.” In T Campbell, J Goldsworthy and A Stone (eds.) Protecting Rights Without a Bill of Rights: Institutional Performance and Reform in Australia. Hampshire, England: Ashgate Publishing Limited, pp 17-39.
Gibson, J. 2015. “Apartheid’s Long Shadow: How Racial Divides Distort South Africa’s Democracy.” Foreign Affairs, 94(2): 41 – 48.
Henriques-Gomes, L. 2018. “Cricket Australia accused of sacking woman for abortion rights tweets.”’ The Guardian, 30 July.
Hill, K. 2013. “Justine Sacco’s Nightmare before Christmas, Twitter-Version.” Forbes, 21 December.
Hytner, M. 2019. “Israel Folau and Rugby Australia settle unfair dismissal claim over social media post.” The Guardian, 4 December.
Jensen, D. C. 2018. “Does core task matter for decision-making? A comparative case study on whether differences in job characteristics affect discretionary street-level decision-making.” Administration and Society, 50 (8): 1125 – 1147.
Kampmark, B. 2018. “Australian Legal Exceptionalism and the Bill of Rights.” Journal for Peace and Justice Studies, 28 (2): 3 – 26.
Kampmark, B. 2017. “The Roz Ward Case: Reflections on Social Media, University Management and Free Speech.” Australian Humanities Review, 62: 26 – 45.
Kemp, S. 2019. “Digital 2019 Global Digital Yearbook Report.” Global Digital Report 2019 – We Are Social. 21 May http://wearesocial.com/global-digital-report-2019
Kemp, S. 2019. “Digital South Africa – DataReportal.’ Global Digital Insights. January https://datareportal.com/reports/digital-2019-south-africa Accessed 29/03/2020.
Lam, H. 2016. “Social media dilemmas in the employment context.” Employee Relations, 38 (3): 420 – 437.
Levin, A. 2015. “Losing the Battle but Winning the War: Why Online Information Should be a Prohibited Ground.” Canadian Labour and Employment Law Journal, 18 (2): 379 - 410.
Lindsay, D. 2014. “The ‘Right to Be Forgotten’ in European Data Protection Law.” In N Witzleb et al. (eds.) Emerging Challenges in Privacy Law: Comparative Perspectives. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, pp 290 – 338.
Lipsky, M. 1980. Street-Level Bureaucracy: Dilemmas of the Individual in Public Service. New York, USA: Russell Sage Foundation.
Lomborg, S. 2017. “A state of flux: Histories of social media research.” European Journal of Communication, 32 (1): 6 – 15.
Magubane, B. 1986. “The Political Economy of the South African Revolution.” African Journal of Political Economy, 1 (1): 1-28.
Mangan, D. 2015. “A Platform for Discipline: Social Media Speech and the Workplace” February 3. SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2559808 Accessed 29/03/2020.
Mangan, D. 2017. “Social media in the workplace.” In D Mangan and L Gillies (eds.) The Legal Challenges of Social Media. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar Publishing Limited, pp 201-221.
Mangan, D. 2018. “Online Speech and the Workplace: Public Right, Private Regulation.” Comparative Labor Law and Policy Journal, 39 (2): 357 - 388.
Mann, M., and Daly, A. 2019. “(Big) data and the North-in-South: Australia’s informational imperialism and digital colonialism.” Television and New Media, 20 (4): 379 – 395.
Manne, K. 2017. Down Girl: The Logic of Misogyny. New York, USA: Oxford University Press.
Mantouvalou, V. 2019. “I Lost My Job over a Facebook Post: Was that Fair? Discipline and Dismissal for Social Media Activity.” International Journal of Comparative Labour Law and Industrial Relations, 35(1): 101 – 125.
McDonald, P., and Thompson, P. 2016. “Social Media(tion) and the Reshaping of Public/Private Boundaries in Employment Relations.” International Journal of Management Reviews, 18: 69- 84.
Meanings and origins of Australian words and idioms. 2017. https://slll.cass.anu.edu.au/centres/andc/meanings-origins/l Accessed 29/03/2020.
Mgrditchian, G. 2015. “Employment & Social Media Privacy: Employer Justification for Access to Private Material.” Rutgers Computer and Technology Law Journal, 41 (1): 108 - 133.
Nel, S. 2016. “Social media and employee speech: the risk of overstepping the boundaries into the firing line.” Comparative and International Law Journal of Southern Africa, 49 (2): 182 - 222.
O’Rouke, A., Pyman, A., and Teicher, J. 2007. “The Right to Privacy and the Conceptualisation of the Person in the Workplace: A Comparative Examination of the EU, US and Australian Approaches.” International Journal of Comparative Labour Law and Industrial Relations, 23(2): 161 - 194.
O’Rouke, A., Pyman, A., Teicher, J., and van Gramberg, B. 2018. “Old wine in new bottles? Regulating employee social media use through termination of employment law: A comparative analysis.” Common Law World Review, 47 (4): 248 - 271.
O’Rouke, A., Teicher, J., and Pyman, A. 2011. “Internet and Email Monitoring in the Workplace: Time for an Alternate Approach.” Journal of Industrial Relations, 53 (4): 522 - 533.
Odeh, L.E. 2012. “A Comparative Analysis of Global North and Global South Economies.” Journal of Sustainable Development in Africa, 12 (3): 338 - 348.
Ornstein, D. 2012. “Social Media Usage in the Workplace Around the World – Developing Law and Practices.” Business Law International, 13(2): 195 - 207.
Papadopoulos, S. 2009. “Revisiting the Public Disclosure of Private Facts in Cyberworld.” Obiter, 30 (1): 30 - 43.
Papworth, L. 2009. “Facebook: Active Users in Australia.” 31 August http://laurelpapworth.com/facebook-active-users-in-australia/ Accessed 29/03/2020.
Park, S. 2014. “Employee Internet Privacy: A Proposed Act that Balances Legitimate Employer Rights and Employee Privacy.” American Business Law Journal, 51 (4): 779 - 841.
Pearl, C. 1958. Wild Men of Sydney. London, UK: W.H. Allen.
Pilkington, E. 2013. “Justine Sacco, PR executive fired over racist tweet, “ashamed.”’ The Guardian, 23 December.
Pivoras, S. and Kaselis, M. 2019. “The Impact of Client Status on Street-Level Bureaucrats’ Identity and Informal Accountability.” Public Integrity, 21(2): 182 - 194.
Plester, B. 2015. “Take it like a man!: Performing hegemonic masculinity through organizational humour.” Ephemera: Theory and Politics in Organisation, 15 (3): 537 – 559.
Potgieter, E. and Moosa, M. 2018. ‘More than a space for interracial contact: Exploring the importance of the workplace for social cohesion and reconciliation in South Africa’ (Reconciliation and Development Report No 1, 2018). https://www.africaportal.org/publications/more-space-interracial-contact-exploring-importance-workplace-social-cohesion-and-reconciliation-south-africa/ Accessed 29/03/2020.
Potgieter, E. 2017. ‘South African Reconciliation Barometer Survey 2017 Report.’ http://www.ijr.org.za/home/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/IJR-Barometer-Report-2017-WEB-final.pdf Accessed 29/03/2020.
Potgieter, M. 2014. Social Media and Employment Law. Claremont, South Africa: Juta and Co.
Rapaport, P. 2013. “Social media policies and unfair dismissal.” Media and Arts Law Review, 18 (2): 75 - 87.
Reddy, S. 2018. “Establishing a test for social media misconduct in the workplace.” Journal of South African Law, 2018 (4): 789 - 819.
Richardson, M., Thomas, J., and Trabsky, M. 2012. “The Internet Imaginary and the Problem of Privacy.” Media and the Arts Law Review, 17 (3): 257 - 268.
Robinson, G. “Folau ‘vindicated’ after calling truce, Rugby Australia says decision would give ‘certainty.” The Sydney Morning Herald, Sydney, 4 December.
Rogers, B. 2019. “Social Media and Worker Organizing under US Law.” International Journal of Comparative Labour Law and Industrial Relations, 35(1): 127 - 152.
Roos, A. 2012. “Privacy in the Facebook Era: A South African Legal Perspective.” South African Law Journal, 129 (2): 375 - 402.
SA population reaches 58.8 million, Department: Statistics South Africa, (Web Page, 29 July 2109) http://www.statssa.gov.za/?p=12362 Accessed 29/03/2020.
Sarkin, J. 1998. “The Development of a Human Rights Culture in South Africa.” Human Rights Quarterly, 20(3): 628 - 665.
Seah, D. 2016. “Social Media and Freedom of Expression in the Workplace: Is the Law and Practice in the UK Fit for Purpose?” Bristol Law Review, 2016 (3): 11-32.
Shaw, L. 2011. “Hate Speech in Cyberspace: Bitterness without Boundaries.” Notre Dame Journal of Law, Ethics and Public Policy, 25 (1): 279 - 304.
Sleep, L. 2019. “Domestic violence, social security and the couple rule” (Research report, 04/2019) Sydney, NSW: ANROWS. https://d2rn9gno7zhxqg.cloudfront.net/wp-content/uploads/2019/07/18032453/RP.17.02_Sleep_D_RR_social-security_couple-rule.pdf Accessed 29/03/2020.
Sleep, L. and Tranter, K. 2018. “Social media in security decision-making in Australia: An archive of truth?” Media and Arts Law Review, 22 (4): 442 - 463.
Statistics South Africa, National Poverty Line 2019, (Statistical Release P0310.1, 31 July 2019) (Web page) http://www.statssa.gov.za/publications/P03101/P031012019.pdf Accessed 29/03/2020
Statistics South Africa, Work and Labour Force (Web page, 26 September 2019) http://www.statssa.gov.za/?page_id=737&id=1 Accessed 29/03/2020
Stewart, A. 2018. Stewart’s Guide to Employment Law. Annandale, NSW: Federation Press.
Stewart, A. et al. 2016. Creighton & Stewarts Labour Law. Annandale, NSW: Federation Press.
Stiegler, C. 2015. “Developments in Employment and Social Media.” Business Lawyer, 71 (1): 321 - 332.
Sunstein, C.R. 2018. #Republic: Divided Democracy in the Age of Social Media. Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press.
Taylor, M. et al. 2016. “Avoiding the misuse of social media by employees.” Network Security, 2016 (5): 8 - 11.
Tchamyou, V. S., Erreygers, G., and Cassimon, D. 2019. “Inequality, ICT and financial access in Africa.” Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 139: 169 - 184.
Thornthwaite, L. 2013. “Social media, unfair dismissal and the regulation of employees’ conduct outside work.” Australian Journal of Labour Law, 26 (2): 164 - 184.
Thornthwaite, L. 2016. “Social Media and Work An emerging privacy.” Precedent, 135: 8 – 13.
Thornthwaite, L. 2018. “Social Media and dismissal: Towards a reasonable expectation of privacy?” Journal of Industrial Relations, 60 (1): 119 - 136.
Tomsen, S. 2017. “Masculinity and homophobic violence in Australia’s recent past.” Sexuality and Culture, 21 (3): 813 - 829.
Van de Merwe, D. et al. 2016. Information and Communications Technology Law. Johannesburg, South Africa: LexisNexis (Pty) Ltd.
Van Dissel, B. 2014. “Social media and the employee’s right to privacy in Australia.” International Data Privacy Law, 4 (3): 222 - 234.
Van Gramberg, B., Teicher, J., and O’Rouke, A. 2014. “Managing electronic communications: a new challenge for human resource managers.” International Journal of Human Resource Management, 25 (16): 2234 - 2252.
Vine, J. 2009. The Larrikin Paradox: An Analysis of Larrikinism’s Democratic Role in Australian Journalism. Ph.D. thesis, Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology University, Melbourne.
Wagstaff, E. and Tranter, K. 2014. “Taking Facebook at face value: The Refugee Review Tribunal’s use of social media evidence.” Australian Journal of Administrative Law, 21: 172 – 186.
World Bank, Poverty and Equity Brief South Africa October 2019, (Web page, October 2019) https://databank.worldbank.org/data/download/poverty/33EF03BB-9722-4AE2-ABC7-AA2972D68AFE/Global_POVEQ_ZAF.pdf Accessed 29/03/2020.
Wragg, P. 2015. “Free Speech Rights at Work: Resolving the Differences between Practice and Liberal Principle.” Industrial Law Journal, 44 (1): 1 - 28.
‘Sensis Social Media Report,’ Sensis (Web Page, 16 October 2018) https://www.sensis.com.au/about/our-reports/sensis-social-media-report Accessed 29/03/2020.
‘The Future is Ours,’ South African History Archives (Web page, 2019) http://www.saha.org.za/youth/the_future_is_ours.htm Accessed 29/03/2020.
‘Yellow Social Media Report 2018,’ Yellow (Web Page, 16 October 2018)
How to Cite
1.
Cornish R, Tranter K. The Cultural, Economic and Technical Milieu of Social Media Misconduct Dismissals in Australia and South Africa. LiC [Internet]. 2020May16 [cited 2020May27];36(2):1-32. Available from: https://journals.latrobe.edu.au/index.php/law-in-context/article/view/113

Send mail to Author


Send Cancel